Skip to main content

Bagel Jay's Bakery & Cafe Gift Cards

Order Now
(You will be able to personalize each one)
$
Select Style:*
Select Predesign Image
Select Predesign Image
Select Predesign Image
Select Predesign Image
Select Predesign Image

User Reviews

› Review from Yelp Logo, small  

These are the 2nd best bagels in Buffalo, the city which suffers the greatest dearth of bagels in the world! The bagels are fresh, thought not NYC fresh....


› Review from Yelp Logo, small  

First off, They have some of the best flavored Cream Cheeses (Schmears) that I have ever tasted. Their Red Pepper Jalapeno has giant chunks of Jalapenos and...


› Review from Yelp Logo, small  

I don't know if Bagel Jays are technically Bagels at all. Because a bagel is supposed to be shaped like an O. If it's baked into a "Jay" shape then doesn't...


See all 32 Reviews at Yelp Logo, small

Disclaimer: GiftCards.com Local gift cards are not issued by, sponsored, affiliated or endorsed by the merchant. Are you this merchant? Claim this page.